Skip to content

What do the U.S. flag and national anthem have to do with liberty and justice?

Ed Williams (Courtesy)

Ed Williams (Courtesy)

We are over 200 years old, and we have gone through many trials and tribulations. I ain’t “no ways tired.” I still breathe hope in the American dream. I still believe that America is worth the struggle. Every time we recite the national anthem – “Star Spangled Banner,” or the Pledge of Allegiance, our voices of liberty and justice ring throughout the land. This cause is a work in progress to establish a more perfect union. It is my core belief that, although, I may not agree with your position, I agree with your right to have your own beliefs, and that everyone should have equal protection under the law. Requiring citizens to stand and recite the Pledge of Allegiance violates the 1st and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Constitution.

So, what does the American flag and national anthem have to do with liberty and justice? The flag, the Pledge and the anthem are relatively recent traditions and they represent what we are willing to defend and die for. Neither the flag, Pledge or anthem are mentioned in our Constitution. Today, there is still discrimination and the playing field is not equal. The reality is that it has never been. A token will not erase all the history or right all the wrongs. It will take time and struggle to get a perfect union. Like all that have come before, we just want the laws to be fair, and we want to be treated with respect. Legitimate authority comes from the people, not from the government. The defenders of freedom are not the government; it is the people. As Dr. King, so eloquently stated, “Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly. I can never be what I ought to be until you are what you ought to be. This is the interrelated structure of reality.”

Why is Colin Kaepernick and so many others frustrated and are not silent about the civil and human rights issues of today? He is taking a stand for what he believes. What Kaepernick, like Dr. King, Muhammad Ali, and so many others have done in the past was a non-violent protest. Kaepernick is using his right as an American citizen to protest and not to be forced to bare allegiance to something he does not believe exist in reality. It is an irony to recite the words to the Pledge or the Anthem about the very concepts of liberty and freedom which he feels he does not have. Many communities have been under attack internally and externally for decades. We struggle for equal protection under the same laws, and that there should not be two sets of rules by those who have pledged to protect and defend and uphold the laws. There is no test or requirement in the US Constitution that requires a citizen not holding office to protect or defend the Constitution or its laws.

The American flag and the national anthem, a symbol and a chorus of words, have not always been used to protect or defend all its people. The National Anthem was not an Anthem until 155 years after the country was founded, it was made so in 1931. There is no mention of political parties or citizenship qualifications in the U.S. Constitution. The Pledge of Allegiance and the national anthem as we know them today were not part of the American lexicon until the 20th century. The founders believe that it was our God-given right to be free and wrote that congress shall make no laws that abridge the freedom of speech or religion. Many do not know that the third verse of the national anthem makes a reference about slaves as traders for fighting to gain their freedom: “No refuge could save the hireling and slave
from the terror of flight, or the gloom of the grave:”

It is contradictory to the pledge that so many faithfully recite every morning in schools: “I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.” It is not right for children to grow up and observe that they do not have equal rights or the same protection under law.

As Americans, we pride ourselves to defend, protect and cherish our liberty. We even send our military, our young and brave, to protect others abroad. Equal rights, opportunity and representation should be the aspiration and the practice in all the land. What I do know about the American experience, even up to today, is that many of our stories and images continue to be excluded from the American narrative with great disparity.

For a perfect Union, we should recognize the value of all the people, and their full potential as humans. It was not so long ago, that Dr. King and the freedom fighters of the sixties stirred the conscious of America in the inequalities and lack of equal opportunities for many of its citizens. Even today, there are still many places in America where people are not welcomed, and are separated. There is often barriers and fences to separate us by class, race, gender, and educational qualification.

Many nationalities have fought for their freedom in the American Revolution, some 25K African American soldiers fought, and they also fought in the Civil War on both sides: Union and Southern slaveholding states. It was a paradox that the white man was fighting for freedom and at the same time denied freedom to the Black man. George Washington, a Virginian, led the American Revolution War Army and fought for liberty. He served as the first president and was a southerner who owned slaves.

Today, 240 years later, the story, and symbols of race supremacy are still used by some of our fellow citizens to demonstrate with contradiction our pledge to the American flag that guarantees liberty and justice for all. There is a need for all Americans to respect the basic right of all to be free. For some, the American flag stands for supremacy for some people and it reminds others of past injustices to them, while for others it represents the hope for a new future. The image and the reality are not the same. This is evidenced by the poverty in the inner cities, and police brutality resulting from their fear of the poor and those that are different. It is in direct conflict with the principle that people from all social backgrounds (social class, gender, ethnicity, and disabilities) want to be represented in all walks of life: education, sports, media, music, films, politics, military, board rooms, etc. In the end, history teaches us that we are stronger together, than divided. Rights without a voice and protection will not last for long.

–Edward E Williams, Ed.D. Chair, Concerned Citizens For Effective Government
Facebook: /KingStoneMountain101/; Twitter: @truthcrushthee2


  1. jessica.crofoot on September 9, 2016 at 5:19 am

    I am gaining in the span of 6-8 thousand bucks on monthly basis for freelancing at home. If you are eager to do easy online task for 2-5 hours each day from ease of your home and make valuable income while doing it… Then this task is for you…


  2. Robert Slackware on September 10, 2016 at 11:36 am

    If you want to see why kirkpatric is so upset. look at obamas justice department, and hillery walking around free. Democrats are the ones refusing to not only prosecute criminals, they are FREEING them by the tens of thousands, and dumping terrorists in poor neighborhoods.

  3. Ed Williams on September 12, 2016 at 2:53 am

    An elected official, uniform services, and officers of the Court should uphold their oaths of office and protect and defend the US constitution for all citizens. It is not about party Democrat or republican. As I stated in the article parties are not mentioned in the US Constitution.

    Kaepernick used a non-violent method of protest that has been off the field of play to protest treatment of unequal protection of the law and justice in our country for certain citizens.
    Kaepernick told’s Steve Wyche: “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color. To me, this is bigger than football and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder.”

    The NFL is a private business that celebrates our liberties, and the Country with the Pledge of Allegiance and the National Anthem. It is contradictory and confusing to deny the same rights for business not to allow its employees an opportunity to protest or speak out in some manner. I believe that it is Mr. Kaepernick’s right to speak out about other citizens’ civil rights not being protected in a non-disrupted manner along as it is not on the playing field and it does not violate the uniform guidelines in any manner, and does not interfere with the operations of the game.
    I do not believe that Mr. Kaepernick actions have caused any disruption or distraction from any football game, no more than the half-time show, the flyover jets, or the national anthem. What his actions have done, However, is made people discuss the real meaning of liberty and justice, and who the Bill of Rights apply. Unlike Tim Tebow a former Denver QB, who a couple of years ago prayed on the field, Colin has not knelled on the field. Tim Tebow is no longer in the NFL because he wore his beliefs on his sleeves.

    Many believe or argue that Mr. Kaepernick should not be kneeling in protest to the National Anthem. I believe it is his right, even though I may not agree with his method of protest by kneeling before a game. There are those who believe that Colin is creating a distraction. I believe that if his action is a distraction, then the team should consider not having an organized Anthem or Pledge at all.

    There are no contract terms that require Mr. Kaepernick to stand or recite either the pledge or national Anthem. The NFL is a corporation is a sports league that is governed by anti-trust laws. Mr. Kasepernick has the Constitutional right to free speech and non-violent protest, but these rights supposedly do not extend to a private corporation, such as the NFL. A uniform should not cause a player to lose all their constitutional rights. It is contradictory for the NFL league to celebrate the same rights, defended by the military abroad and other uniformed services at home.
    It is ironic that the NFL and the other sport leagues celebrate our liberty and freedom of speech rights, The NFL should with the same enthusiasm defend the players’ right not to stand and pledge allegiance. Mr. Kaepernick should not be fired or let go because he does not want to recite the pledge or sing the National Anthem. Colin should have due process as spelled out by the anti-trust labor laws and collective bargaining agreements.

    I do not believe that because Mr. Kaepernick makes a lot of money, wears a uniform, and has a good job that he should be silent on issues of justice and equal protection for all citizens. A person does not have to experience the injustice himself to speak out about others injustice and unfair treatment. Mr. Kaepernick has stated that he does not believe that there is liberty and justice for all.

    The logic used by the government that the Bill of Rights and the equal protection clause does not apply to private business does not make sense. This means that Bill of Rights would not to apply to a person at work for the most part, unemployed, a private company or a government employee in uniform with contract restrictions. So, how many people would be protected by the Bill of Rights?

    As ruled by US Supreme Court, in the case Citizens United Against Hobby Lobby A corporation has free speech rights. If so, then it should also apply to the employees. The Supreme court majority logic was that a corporation is a collection of people, well so is the NFL. Everyone should have equal protection under the law.

    • Robert Slackware on September 17, 2016 at 8:43 pm

      so where is the outrage when NFL took away his second amendment right?

  4. Robert Slackware on September 17, 2016 at 8:38 pm

    No the irony is you claiming he has a first and 14th amendment right inside the stadium when the NFL took AWAY his 2nd amendment right there last year. THAT is what he should be protesting. you don’t hear about ARMED black teen shot for no reason, or cop though he had a gun when he DOES have one.
    I can’t think of any cop shootings that aren’t in democrat strongholds where they ignore your rights.

    • Ed Williams on September 22, 2016 at 8:00 am

      I believe in all the Bill of Rights, including the 2nd amendment. I strongly believe in the right to bear arms. I do not agree with banning firearms. I do believe that there are places and situations were people should not be allowed to carry guns. For example guns should not be allowed in the stadium as long as there is sufficient and adequate security and police.

      • Robert Slackware on September 22, 2016 at 2:05 pm

        Do you see the news at all? When there are lots of cops is WHEN you need a gun the most.

      • Robert Slackware on October 23, 2016 at 5:23 pm

        it is the police and security that make you need the gun. probably way more of them than crooks in the stadium. It is LEGAL for them to kill you, shooting them first is your only option.