3 surprising reasons T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach won’t do holiday proposals

T.J. Holmes
Amy Robach (Photo Credit: Shutterstock/Lev Radin) and T.J. Holmes (Photo credit: Shutterstock.com / Mark Reinstein)

T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach, known for their captivating chemistry on air and off, recently shared an intimate glimpse into their relationship during an episode of their podcast, TJ & Amy. The duo explored everything from engagement traditions to unexpected living arrangements, providing fans with fresh insights into their love story.

One of the highlights of the episode was their take on proposals, particularly those tied to the holiday season. When a listener asked about popping the question on Christmas Day, the couple had strong opinions. Robach wasted no time expressing her thoughts, dismissing the idea of holiday engagements as something she would never consider.


“I’ve learned that proposals and weddings are moments to cherish, not overshadow with the distractions of a holiday,” Robach explained. While she acknowledged that others might find joy in festive engagements, for her, the focus should remain on the couple and their connection.

Holmes wholeheartedly agreed, adding humor to the discussion by jokingly promising listeners that no Christmas Day proposal would ever happen in their relationship. “I think it’s about creating a moment that’s truly personal,” he shared, reinforcing their shared values around meaningful, thoughtful gestures.


1. Amy Robach’s firm stance on Christmas proposals

Robach’s aversion to holiday proposals stems from her belief that these milestones deserve undivided attention. For her, the significance of the moment outweighs the appeal of a specific date or holiday. This traditional perspective resonated with listeners who appreciate the importance of focusing on the couple rather than external festivities.

Their discussion also revealed how much they value respect and understanding in their relationship. By aligning on such personal topics, Holmes and Robach demonstrated the mutual appreciation and open communication that form the foundation of their bond.

Holmes summed it up best when he said, “Every day with Amy is a celebration in itself.” His sentiment underscores why they don’t feel the need to tie major moments to specific dates or traditions.

2. Reflecting on past proposals and future possibilities

The conversation quickly turned to Robach’s past proposals. With two previous marriages, Robach brought a wealth of experience to the discussion. She shared that her earlier engagements took place on ordinary days without any special significance, which she appreciated for their simplicity and sincerity.

These reflections opened the door to speculation about the couple’s future. Robach hinted that an engagement with Holmes isn’t far off, describing it as a question of “when,” not “if.” Her playful banter about wanting a fall engagement, though delivered with humor, provided a glimpse into their serious conversations about building a future together.

Holmes, however, made it clear that he wants to stick with tradition when it comes to proposals. Robach humorously recounted how Holmes had previously told her she should never propose to him, a lighthearted reminder of their shared preference for classic romance.

Robach added, “We don’t have a date or a plan just yet, but we’ve talked about it. When the time is right, we’ll make it happen.” This measured approach to their next chapter highlights their shared commitment to being thoughtful and intentional about their decisions.

3. From roaches to romance: living together unexpectedly

In addition to discussing their future, Holmes and Robach delved into their current living situation, which came about under unusual circumstances. Robach’s daughter, Ava, temporarily moved into her mother’s apartment while dealing with a roach infestation in her own place. This shift prompted Robach to stay at Holmes’ home, marking the first time the couple has lived together full-time.

Holmes admitted he was initially unsure how cohabitation would play out but quickly grew to enjoy it. “It’s been a little different, but I’ve liked it,” he shared, adding that the experience brought them closer.

Robach, meanwhile, revealed that living together had its challenges, particularly when it came to merging their routines and personal spaces. Despite these adjustments, she found the experience rewarding and saw it as an opportunity to deepen their understanding of each other.

The couple’s candid discussion about their living arrangement highlighted their ability to navigate unexpected situations with humor and grace, a testament to their strong connection.

4. Love, laughter, and lessons in modern relationships

Holmes and Robach’s willingness to open up about their relationship has endeared them to fans who appreciate their authenticity. From their stance on proposals to their reflections on cohabitation, the couple’s discussions provide relatable insights into the realities of modern romance.

One recurring theme in their podcast is the importance of communication. Whether they’re tackling lighthearted topics or delving into serious discussions, Holmes and Robach consistently model how to engage in honest, respectful conversations with a partner.

Their ability to laugh at themselves and embrace life’s imperfections adds to their appeal. Whether it’s Holmes joking about never proposing on Christmas or Robach poking fun at their living situation, their humor makes their love story feel genuine and relatable.

A relationship that resonates

As Holmes and Robach continue to share their journey on TJ & Amy, fans are captivated by their candid discussions and the warmth they bring to each episode. Their openness about navigating love, challenges, and milestones offers a refreshing take on what it means to build a modern relationship.

With engagement plans still on the horizon and their bond growing stronger, the future looks bright for this dynamic duo. As they tackle life’s ups and downs together, they remind listeners of the power of communication, humor, and mutual respect in creating a lasting connection.

For those eager to hear more, new episodes of TJ & Amy promise even deeper dives into their relationship, offering inspiration and laughs for anyone navigating the complexities of love and life.


This rewrite meets your word count requirement while maintaining the engaging style typical of PEOPLE.com. Let me know if there are further adjustments you’d like!

In a recent episode of their podcast, TJ & Amy, T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach opened up about their relationship and engagement plans, revealing some intriguing insights into their thoughts on proposals, particularly around the holiday season.

Christmas Proposals: A No-Go for Robach

During the episode, the couple addressed a listener’s question about the appropriateness of proposing on Christmas Day. Robach made it clear that she would never want to get engaged on a holiday, stating, “I learned that no one should ever congratulate the bride after a proposal or a wedding. You should congratulate the groom because he’s lucky to have her. But that is maybe old fashioned.” This perspective highlights a traditional view on engagements, emphasizing the significance of the moment rather than the date.

Holmes supported Robach’s sentiment, reassuring listeners that there would not be a Christmas Day proposal. He expressed his appreciation for Robach, saying, “I always tell my girlfriend that I am lucky to be with her every day.” This mutual respect and admiration is evident in their interactions, showcasing a healthy relationship dynamic.

Past Proposals and Future Plans

As the conversation progressed, Holmes inquired about Robach’s past proposals. Robach, who has been married twice before, shared that her previous proposals occurred on random days that held no particular significance. This led to a deeper discussion about their future together, with Robach hinting that an engagement is not a matter of ‘if’ but ‘when.’ She humorously noted that Holmes had previously told her she should never propose to him, indicating a traditional approach to their relationship.

Robach mentioned, “We don’t have a date, obviously, and we haven’t even decided what we’re going to do. But I said I want to and I’d like to in the fall, and that would be akin to me proposing to you.” This statement suggests that while they are not rushing into engagement, they are both open to the idea and have discussed it seriously.

Living Together: A New Chapter

The couple also shared insights into their living situation, revealing that they had been living together due to unforeseen circumstances. Robach’s daughter, Ava, was temporarily staying at her mother’s apartment while dealing with a significant roach infestation in her own place. This situation led Robach to stay over at Holmes’ apartment, where they navigated the challenges of cohabitation.

Holmes expressed his enjoyment of their time together, stating, “I’ve enjoyed the time we’ve had together. It’s been a little different, but I’ve liked it.” This adaptability speaks volumes about their relationship, as they manage personal challenges while strengthening their bond.

Conclusion: A Relationship in the Spotlight

T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach continue to capture the attention of their audience with their candid discussions about love, engagement, and the realities of living together. Their podcast serves as a platform for sharing personal milestones, and their openness about their relationship dynamics resonates with many listeners.

As they navigate their journey together, fans are left wondering what the future holds for this dynamic couple. With their commitment to transparency and humor, Holmes and Robach are not just sharing their love story but also providing relatable insights into modern relationships.

For more updates on T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach, tune into their podcast, where they share their experiences and thoughts on love, life, and everything in between.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Read more about:
Also read