When world No. 1 golfer Scottie Scheffler faced charges after an incident at a PGA Championship event, the outcome of his arrest sparked a conversation about race and privilege in the American justice system. Scheffler — who is white and has an estimated net worth between $50 and $100 million — was arrested for allegedly driving recklessly, ignoring police signals and injuring an officer. Despite the severity of the charges, including a felony, he was released within hours and even managed to joke about the experience later.
The incident and its aftermath
According to reports, Scheffler attempted to circumvent a police barricade at the golf course, which had been erected after a fatal accident involving a shuttle bus. In the process, he allegedly dragged an officer with his car, resulting in the officer sustaining injuries. The charges against Scheffler included reckless driving, third-degree criminal mischief and second-degree assault of a police officer.
However, the response to Scheffler’s actions and the subsequent legal proceedings highlight a stark contrast when compared to similar situations involving Black people. The ease with which Scheffler navigated the incident — including being offered a sandwich and having his tee time rescheduled — stands in sharp contrast to the fear and uncertainty that many Black individuals face in the criminal justice system.
Race, privilege and justice
The handling of Scheffler’s case raises questions about how race and wealth can influence one’s experience with law enforcement and the justice system. The notion that jail is for “the little people and the Black people,” as suggested by the narrative, underscores the disparities that exist. It also brings to mind the tragic case of Breonna Taylor, who was shot and killed by police in the same city, underscoring the different outcomes that can result from interactions with law enforcement.
The ability of Scheffler to ‘compartmentalize’ and perform in his golf game after the arrest was lauded by broadcasters, yet this leniency and admiration are privileges that are often not extended to Black individuals in similar circumstances.
Reflection on justice in Black and White
The juxtaposition of Scheffler’s experience with the broader context of racial injustice invites reflection on the representation of Lady Justice. If the depictions were to reflect reality, perhaps the sword she holds would bear a message that justice is not applied equally to all.
The case of Scottie Scheffler serves as a poignant example of the disparities that can arise from the intersection of race, wealth and justice. It is a reminder that for many, the scales of justice are perceived to be imbalanced, and the conversation about equality and fairness in the legal system must continue.
