On Nov. 22, twin brothers David and Darren Stith filed a federal lawsuit against Universal Music Group, claiming they are owed millions in royalties for their contributions to Nelly’s first two albums, Country Grammar and Nellyville. The lawsuit was filed in the Central District of California and has drawn attention due to the brothers’ significant role in the early career of the St. Louis rapper.
Background of the lawsuit
The Stith brothers, who own an independent label called D2 in St. Louis, assert that they were instrumental in promoting Nelly and his group, the St. Lunatics. They allege that they introduced Nelly to music producer Jason Epperson, which helped launch his career. According to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, the brothers claim they signed contracts that entitled them to collect royalties from the aforementioned albums and several songs recorded by the St. Lunatics.
Allegations against Universal Music Group
The Stiths are seeking up to $10 million in unpaid royalties. Their attorney, Jay Kanzler Jr., has stated that Universal Music Group is allegedly manipulating song titles to avoid paying the rightful royalties. This practice, according to the Stiths, has resulted in them receiving payment for only one version of a song while Universal collects revenue from multiple versions.
Demand for transparency
As part of their lawsuit, the Stith brothers are demanding that Universal Music Group provide documentation detailing how much money is owed to them for the songs they helped create. Kanzler emphasized the need for transparency, stating, “Tell us what they are and how much you know you’ve made off of them, and give us our percentage.” This request highlights the brothers’ desire to ensure they are compensated fairly for their contributions to Nelly’s success.
Impact on the music industry
This lawsuit raises important questions about the treatment of artists and producers in the music industry, particularly regarding royalty distribution. Many independent artists and producers often face challenges in receiving fair compensation for their work, especially when dealing with major record labels. The Stith brothers’ case could set a precedent for how contracts are honored and how royalties are calculated in the future.
The outcome of this lawsuit could have significant implications not only for the Stith brothers but also for other artists and producers who feel they have been wronged by major record labels. As the case unfolds, it will be crucial to monitor how Universal Music Group responds and whether this situation prompts broader discussions about fairness and transparency in the music industry.
