FX’s ‘People vs. O.J. Simpson’ proves power of public perception

Public relations professionals have long embraced the idea that public perception is more important than actual truth. The way the public perceives something can often be the exact opposite of the real facts, but public perception has a way of outweighing and eventually eclipsing the truth. Few examples highlight offer a better case study of this behavior than FX’s adaptation of “American Crime Story: The People vs. O.J. Simpson.”

In episode four titled “100% Not Guilty,”  we see how public perception worked to cloud the facts and real evidence surrounding one of the most controversial murder trials in history.  The trial pitted state prosecutors Marcia Clark and Christopher Darden against Simpson’s legal defense team consisting of Robert Shapiro, Johnny Cochran and Robert Kardashian.  Clark and Darden were attacked by the public for their less than polished exteriors. During focus groups for jury selection, Clark was constantly referred to as a b—h, and not relatable. Women didn’t like her hair, and she was instructed to wear dresses instead of pantsuits to seem more feminine and “likable.” Darden suffered from razor bumps and often looked disheveled; viewers labeled him angry and resentful. Simpson’s team on the other hand, was the exact opposite of the prosecuting attorneys. Lead by the debonair Robert (Bob) Shapiro, the defense was as high brow as their client. Robert Kardashian (father of the famous Kardashians) was well-heeled and handsome and the star of the defense; Johnnie Cochran was as flashy as an A-list actor and as motivational as the silver-tongued Jesse Jackson.  While the defense was certainly more primped and polished, it wasn’t a fair comparison as the defense team consisted of high-powered wealthy attorneys with thriving practices filled with affluent clientele, while the prosecution consisted of state employees.


Everyone knows the outcome of the trial of the century, but we will never know the true degree of influence public perception had on the jury.  Was O.J.Simpson able to escape a murder conviction based on the fact that he was a good-looking ex-football player with an all-star team of privileged and likable attorneys? Some would say that’s exactly what happened. Others would be more objective, but few would deny these intangible variables didn’t have an effect on the jury’s final verdict.  From a racist cop pegged as an accomplice, to an overzealous prosecution to the carefully orchestrated theatrical speeches delivered to oratorical perfection by Cochran, and sadly to the victims’ families that often didn’t receive high sympathy marks from viewers, and lastly, realizing that the word most women quoted in reference to Simpson while on trial was “handsome”; there were definitely underlying factors that affected the outcome of the O.J. Simpson trial. What makes this case such a great example is that it displays the many variables that go into how we form opinions of others.  Everyone should be innocent until proven guilty, however, there are so many factors that go into how we perceive and judge others, it’s almost unrealistic to assume the justice system can cut through the bias that is public perception.

Recommended
You May Also Like
Join Our Newsletter
Picture of Dr. Christal Jordan-Jennings
Dr. Christal Jordan-Jennings
Dr. Christal D. Jordan Jennings is a journalist and professional entertainment publicist with several years of experience in celebrity marketing and branding. Jordan worked in the corporate PR sector before relocating to Atlanta, GA and founding Enchanted Branding and Public Relations in 2008. The company specializes in public relations strategy, media training/consultation, and crisis communication in service of notable celebrity talent such as TLC’s Chilli, Roy Jones Jr.,Kenan Thompson, and more. Further, Jordan serves as a journalist. She serves as editor-in-chief for Lenox & Parker, Sr. Editor with with Rolling Out and Sr. Features writer with Collider, where she specializes in stories that emphasize the importance of empowering women. Jordan earned her Bachelor of Arts degree in Organizational Communications and her Master of Arts in Mass Communications from the University of Oklahoma. Most recently, Jordan started a YouTube channel pulling from her own experiences with celebrity endorsement and strategic relationships. The channel, entitled From Christal with Love XO, boasts over 27k subscribers and works to celebrate love and relationships from a progressive lens. She is also the host of Fox 5 Atlanta’s bi-weekly segment on celebrity relationships. After twenty years of notable stellar contributions in journalism, public relations and literature, Christal received an honorary doctoral degree in Literary Studies from TIUA in June 2024.
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Read more about: